[ Previous ]   [ Next ]

Remedy

Inequality

David Brooks alerted his readers to this interesting essay by Tyler Cowen on income inequality: “In terms of immediate political stability, there is less to the income inequality issue than meets the eye. Most analyses of income inequality neglect two major points. First, the inequality of personal well-being is sharply down over the past hundred years and perhaps over the past twenty years as well. Bill Gates is much, much richer than I am, yet it is not obvious that he is much happier if, indeed, he is happier at all. I have access to penicillin, air travel, good cheap food, the Internet and virtually all of the technical innovations that Gates does. Like the vast majority of Americans, I have access to some important new pharmaceuticals, such as statins to protect against heart disease. To be sure, Gates receives the very best care from the world’s top doctors, but our health outcomes are in the same ballpark. I don’t have a private jet or take luxury vacations, and—I think it is fair to say—my house is much smaller than his. I can’t meet with the world’s elite on demand. Still, by broad historical standards, what I share with Bill Gates is far more significant than what I don’t share with him.” (…)
“All that said, income inequality does matter—for both politics and the economy. To see how, we must distinguish between inequality itself and what causes it. But first let’s review the trends in more detail.
The numbers are clear: Income inequality has been rising in the United States, especially at the very top. The data show a big difference between two quite separate issues, namely income growth at the very top of the distribution and greater inequality throughout the distribution. The first trend is much more pronounced than the second, although the two are often confused.”

According to Cowen the financial industry is largely responsible for the raise in income inequality. But there is no remedy in sight.
The only comfort is that growing income inequality doesn’t necessarily mean growing happiness inequality: “Many studies suggest that above a certain level more money brings only marginal increments of happiness.”


10 comments Last_comment
Other people's income remains somehow a little abstract to me: it's not mine to spend . As a result it provokes little jealousy.
In The Moral Consequences of Economic Growth Benjamin Freedman argues that people tend to measure their welfare by reference to other peoples welfare. One example is wanting a more expensive car because your neighbor just bought a new car. This human tendency may obscure the fact that, at least in most of the Western world, people have never been better off in all of human history.

Today I saw that Huid en Haar was available at the local super market. What more can a person desire? Food and superb literature within reach of almost evryone. Quite an improvement from having to hunt for your own food all day and running the risk of being eaten yourself along the way.
not a Marxist
Mr Grunberg, if you think the above article is interesting you are most certainly not a Marxist.
( http://www.arnongrunberg.com/blog/1603-a-long-talk )
No remedy
Yesterday, I finally finished the last pages of ‘Huid en haar’. I was left with no surprise, no drama, no euphoria, only a mild melancholy. As it always is. After any great adventure.
Herman
I never claimed to be a Marxist.
Arnon Grunberg
I also wonder why Mr Van den Berg would call you a Marxist.
Perhaps there is more than one definition of what a Marxist is.

I still have to read Huid en Haar, you most economic novel yet, I was told.
Gelukkig nieuwjaar Arnon!
Arnon
Too bad, I'm profoundly taken by Marxistic Jews.
money & happiness
If 'love is business' happiness might always be related to your personal income, unless you happen to be some kind of zen-bhuddist monk, a detached onlooker, just watching this game (or play) we call life...
You may be perfectly happy e.g. reading 'your life away'!
(See 'A Lifetime's Reading')
And, 'you can only eat so many steaks'.

A Very Happy New Year to all!
Remedy
Santé !
Happy 2011 to all, here and there !