2010/11/07 Amsterdam
Divorces
Winnings
Nicholas D. Kristof wrote in today’s Times:
"Robert H. Frank of Cornell University, Adam Seth Levine of Vanderbilt University, and Oege Dijk of the European University Institute recently wrote a fascinating paper suggesting that inequality leads to more financial distress. They looked at census data for the 50 states and the 100 most populous counties in America, and found that places where inequality increased the most also endured the greatest surges in bankruptcies.
Here’s their explanation: When inequality rises, the richest rake in their winnings and buy even bigger mansions and fancier cars. Those a notch below then try to catch up, and end up depleting their savings or taking on more debt, making a financial crisis more likely.
Another consequence the scholars found: Rising inequality also led to more divorces, presumably a byproduct of the strains of financial distress. Maybe I’m overly sentimental or romantic, but that pierces me. It’s a reminder that inequality isn’t just an economic issue but also a question of human dignity and happiness."
Keeping up with the Smith's is the source of economic growth, unhappiness and bankruptcies.
As often I sympathize with Mr. Kristof’s opinions.
But I don’t see an alternative to our common belief in economic growth. Our system and our pension funds are built on this dogma.
14 comments
Alas ... but no, I don't think we have to adhere to this doctrine and way of life.
It's still a personal choice.
Doomed to be suckers
Of course if we don't believe in Santa Claus, he'll just stop sliding down people's chimneys. If we stop believing in the banks and investment funds then they'll be bankrupt by 4 pm in the afternoon. So yes, we may have no choice but to keep believing in them and loaning them our money without asking for collateral.
I saw panic in the eyes of my ex-employee when I told him I sold my car - he's driving a BMW- and that I didn't intend to buy another one, but use public transport instead. For years he tried to exceed me and then this.
money...
@ Carlos
'loaning them our money; - lending
'keeping up with the Smith's'?
The expression used to be 'Keeping up with the Jones's'.
A funny and interesting change of words.
Are the Smiths' no longer fit to be compared with?
Too poor, too far out of any statistics?
Some decades ago, this 'need for economic growth', was derided as complete nonsense already.
We don't need economic growth, we probably need to return to some economy without any banks involved in the process...!
Bert
loan =- lend money at interest (in this case, lend and loan are interchangeable)
Of course, we all know that the love of money is the root of all evil. (Although Eve committed the original sin apparently.)
Timothy 6:10: "For the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil. Some people, eager for money, have wandered from the faith and pierced themselves with many griefs."
I suspect, however, that those afflicted by the lack of money are pierced by even greater griefs.
Maybe I’m overly sentimental or romantic, but that pierces me. It’s a reminder that inequality isn’t just an economic issue but also a question of human dignity and happiness."
The sentence confuses me. I had the impression that dignity was measured by fininancial succes.
Following this, one can see that the scarcity of goods is not exclusively a natural, an economical phenomenon. If an individual's happiness and one's desires depend on what someone else has, rather than what one actually needs, then this state of affairs is a big generator of scarcity.
Money isnt the key to happiness, but with enough of it you can let someone have one made an old r 'n b singer told us.
Careca
"...you can let someone have one made an old r 'n b singer told us."
Made what? You can let someone be happy?
The old R&B singer was Solomon Burke?
Don't quite get your message...
Please be more specific and clearer.
Bert, the answers:
The first one is from google, although not 100 % reliable the question help me have a key made has 585.000.000 answers.
The second one: the singer was Tiny Grimes (he is an expert on financial issues:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=50R9RrowhqA )
So it is Tiny's message, not mine, all credits to him (which you can also see as a financial lesson)
René Girard devoted a life-time study on the issue of "Keeping up with........", or mimesis. Although mimesis is the way we learn and educate ourselves, once the goal of this process is corrupted it ends into "Violence and the Sacred". René Girard is a member of the Academie Française
Brands boeken
Alô, Mr Grunberg! Ik heb zojuist zitten genieten van je optreden bij Mr. Brands. Heel fris en fruitig allemaal...en alwéer een hilarisch boek! Het gaat goed met je? De koning is dood, lang leve de koning! Ik benoem je bij deze tot de nieuwe nummer 1 !! van de nog te benoemen grote 3 !!
Alle hartelijks van Jakomijn
inequality
As Aristotle and Spinoza have amply argued: if you create inequality more than 5 times the basis income, society will never get its moral compass right!
Rob Gast
If you read my essay on Otto Weininger you will find quotes by Girard.