Arnon Grunberg

Jung

Uncanny

David Cronenberg’s movie “A Dangerous Method” is about the unraveling friendship between Jung and Freud.
It’s doubtful whether the movie does justice to Freud’s ideas, but then again a movie is not a college.
While leaving the movie theater I overheard a conversation between a man and a woman. The woman said: “I always knew that psychoanalysis was all about dreams.” And the man answered: “I’m not capable of remembering any of my dreams, that’s why therapy didn’t work for me.” A.O. Scott wrote in The Times: “It ["A Dangerous Method"] also at times has the quiet, uncanny mood of a horror movie, albeit one whose monsters are invisible, living inside the souls they menace.”

Uncanny or not, I would say that “A Dangerous Method” argues that too much civilization might be a blessing, but it’s a disease as well.

I sided with the character of Otto Gross who convinces Jung that he should sleep with his patient.

Of course, Christian culture brought us carnival, a period in which we are allowed – in a controlled manner – to stop controlling our urges, albeit for a short period of time.

The atheist should be allowed to overcome his civilization in a civilized manner as well.

Sex might be horrific, but Mr. Cronenberg knows his Freud: there is nothing as uncanny as civilization itself.